Oh, I see, I see! Yes, it is totally fishy, isn't it! But I'm not sure about what else can make the Sheriff a suspect. After all, he hasn't been here. And the warning about the liar was before he returned. But his being here for that first murder also has fishy timing...

But enough about fish - I'm going to be hungry!

[blushes] Oh, thank you... I've never done anything quite like this before... And you're helping me out tremendously!
But I guess we have a suspect. I'm not all that confident about confronting him alone though. Should we call the Sheriff?